The decision between repair and replacement depends on several factors, but age is often the primary consideration. If your West Athens home has its original 1950s-1960s roof that hasn’t been replaced, you’re likely looking at replacement rather than ongoing repairs.
Signs that point toward replacement include multiple leak areas, significant granule loss across large sections, curling or missing shingles in various locations, and daylight visible through the roof boards from your attic. When repairs start costing more than 30% of replacement cost, replacement usually makes more financial sense.
However, newer roofs or those with localized damage often benefit from targeted repairs. We provide honest assessments because our reputation depends on customers who trust our recommendations. If repairs will solve your problems for years to come, that’s what we’ll recommend. If you’re throwing money at a roof that’s fundamentally worn out, we’ll tell you that too.